One Hour One Life Forums

Families for the most part settled on already existing infrastructure so there was a lot less dying off I would guess.

2. is actually quite normal.

Do you even teach anyone anywhere how to kill? A lot of people don't know at all. Besides many more people are newbies or have no reaction time to do any of it. Most "PvP" happens between older players. Not that many veterans available, with weapons ready, at any one point.

Groups of people with PvP oriented inclinations will most likely be the griefers. You are giving them a huge advantage with this.

You imagine people interacting in the game off screen, but what happens in reality is people coordinating on discord will "meta game" into targeting other random players one by one.

Group advantage shouldn't be overwhelming.

Another thing is that right now I can see a griefer in action and stab him right away. Done. With this change griefers will be able to do so much damage before anyone can group up to kill him. Earlier towns even worse, how many iron for knifes and ropes/string for bows/arrows do you have available? What happens if a griefer takes one? Do you need 3 at all times to counter him? What if they are twins? You need 5 and hope they don't mass murder everyone before people coordinate? What if they are quads? Is it even possible to defeat them?

You said on the other topic that you wanted families to last. The family you gave as an example was a family that was murdered by 3 griefers. The griefers were pretty much 1 to 1 in comparison with the rest of the town. They had little chance but with this they would definitely have no chance at all for a defense.

You also nerfed curses to quads because of unfair advantage but now you give them 2x walking speed when targeting a single person? Doesn't make sense to me.

Please no.

There is next to no situations where multiple people are available to chase a griefer. Most towns are composed mostly by newbies or people who had next to no experience with killing. This change would make it impossible for the one guy that can protect town to not be able to do so.

Group advantage should be a supportive thing, in the forms of curses and pads, not magic posses.

If we has towns it could be cool if we had some sort of "unlocking tech" mechanism over time. With town being able to unlock different types of tech.

That said, our current tech is too much "all or nothing", I don't see any way of locking part of the tech tree besides oil, engines or oddities like radios or cars. Maybe pies? But what's the point? lol

You give us 4 but don't actually give us meaningful interactions.

If you check the last generations you can see that most of them were killed by their own family. It was internal griefing. As usual.

Some resources should definitely ran out after a while. Alum, Lapis and Cinnabar are definitely some that should NOT go out though.

Alternatively to having a vein, you could not destroy them during the creation of the dye. Make them reusable.

In addition, it would be great to be able to dye mordant already dyed clothing. It would be awesome if we could change the color of existing clothing that way.

I've tried the mod out and found an issue with the notifications:

I never saw the notification for the apocalypse and I'm sure I'm missed some other notifications as well. I guess the search functionality overrides it?

No.

The people most likely to do this kind of grief are the discord griefers which don't need to spawn as twins to play together. They can just spawn anywhere and ask others on discord to curse a specific name. Even with a distance limit they can just spend a couple minutes walking to curse someone (map not that big).

What we need in my opinion is a number that cuts just above the "curse noise" and any potentially abuse so that the system target only those who are consistently cursed over and over again.

Where do you see that? Nothing on the frontpage.

I would like to remind everyone on how exploitable that kind of system is. We need a certain amount of minimum curses to avoid griefers being able to band together and send people to donkey town.

@Twisted you specially should be very aware of how this kind of thing can be abused. What if all griefers in discord cursed you during a live stream? You would be pretty much put on donkey town for the rest of the week.